Court of Criminal Appeals, Place 9

Rotate phone sideways to see all candidates

Court & PlaceRepublicanDemocratNotes/Other

John Messinger (R-Austin)

Holly Taylor (D-Austin)

Candidate (L)
Candidate (G)
Candidate (I)

Campaign Mailing AddressP.O. Box 305
Pflugerville, TX
78691-0305

1101 West 34th Street, No. 119
Austin, TX  78705

Campaign Phone(512) 365-4026(512) 643-3637
Campaign Websitemessingerforjustice.comhollytforjudge.com
Social Media Linkstwitter
facebook
linkedin
twitter

linkedin

facebook
youtube
Bar Card Number2405370500794721
Current OccupationOffice of the State Prosecuting Attorney
since 2011
Director of the Public Integrity and Complex Crimes Division
Travis County District Attorney's Office
Years of Texas Residency

22 years

Native Texan
JD School & YearBaylor University
2006
University of Texas
1995
Other EducationNew Jersey Institute of Technology, B.S./M.S. Marketing, 1999/2000Master's of Public Affairs, University of Texas
1995
B.A., Rice University
1989
Year of State Bar Licensure20061995
Legal Experience - NonjudicialOffice of the State Prosecuting Attorney
since 2011

McLennan County District Attorney's Office
- 150 briefs in Courts of Appeals
-120 Petitions for discretionary review
- 90 briefs in Court of Criminal Appeals
-45 oral arguments

Travis County District Attorney’s Office:
Director, Public Integrity and Complex Crimes Division (2024-25)
Assistant Director for Post-Conviction Matters and Complex Litigation Support, Civil Rights Division (2022-24)
Team Lead, Appeals Section  (2021-22)
Assistant District Attorney, Conviction Integrity Unit (2020-21)
Assistant District Attorney, Special Prosecutions Div. (2010-15)
Assistant District Attorney, Appeals Team (1999-2001, 2003-10)

Texas Court of Criminal Appeals:
Rules Attorney and Staff Attorney (2015-20)
Staff Attorney (1996-99)

Jury Trial Experience2 trials as attorney5 trials
Appellate Judicial Experience
Other Judicial Experience
Board CertificationsCriminal Appellate Law
Courts AdmittedU.S. Supreme Court
Texas state courts
Honors and Awards
  • Member, Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Rules Committee
  • Faculty, Dawson Conference on Criminal Appeals
Faculty, Texas State Bar’s Advanced Criminal Law Course
Prior Elections2024 General Election, 3rd Court of Appeals Place 2
49% vs Maggie Ellis
2024 Primary, 3rd Court of Appeals Place 2

Unopposed

2024 Texas General Election
Presiding Judge, Texas Court of Criminal Appeals
41.9% (4.56 million votes)

Most Recent Bar Polls2026 - 799 24%

2026 - 1529 47%

2024: Holly 2,052, Her opponent 1,538 

(The incumbent received more votes in the State Bar Poll, but lost in the primary election.)
Key Endorsements (Max 5)20 State Republican Executive Committee members
Grassroots America - We the People
True Texas Project
Montgomery County Tea Party
Dr. Steve Hotze
Texas AFL-CIO COPE
Congressman Greg Casar
State Senator Sarah Eckhardt
Houston Lawyers Association
Texas Gulf Coast Area Labor Federation
Judicial Philosophy (Max 250 words)It should be obvious, but in a system of law you cannot have justice without enforcing the law.  Yet too many judges do what seems right in their own eyes instead of following the law as written.  
All Republican judicial candidates say they won't legislate from the bench.  More often than not, you just have to trust them because they have no record to prove it.  I have a written record of advocacy as a prosecutor---hundreds of briefs, petitions, motions---that proves my faithfulness to the law.

Holly is dedicated to building and sustaining a justice system that is:

  • Independent and impartial;
  • Grounded in the Constitution and the rule of law;
Fair and just, treating all who come before the court with dignity and humanity.
Misc•chair of the State Bar’s Pattern Jury Charges—Criminal Committee
•John has filed 115 petitions for discretionary review in the Court of Criminal Appeals and has represented the State in over 90 cases granted review by that court. He has also represented the State in over 150 cases in the intermediate courts of appeals. John has presented oral argument in over 40 cases, split almost evenly between the Court of Criminal Appeals and intermediate courts of appeals.
•Serves at local church and pregnancy center
•Former adjunct law professor, the University of Texas School of Law
•Co-Chair, Austin Bar Association committee that provides free monthly trainings and annual ethics training for lawyers
•Spouse and mother to four children
Date Submitted by CandidateSubmitted by candidate
1-31-26
Submitted by candidate
11-25-25

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This